US Stocks Reach New Valuation Extreme

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, and the one on the right reflects stock market valuation levels. Stock market pricing indicates whether stocks are cheap or expensive relative to earnings, but it is a poor indicator of market timing. We do not recommend selling stocks because the market valuation is high, but we would advise investors to be circumspect about adding new positions without careful investigation of the underlying value.

Bull/Bear Market

The Bull/Bear indicator remains at 40%, warning of a bear market ahead.

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The unemployment rate and continued claims are gradually rising, indicating the US economy is slowing rather than the dramatic collapse suggested by recent BLS job growth revisions.

Continued Claims & the Unemployment Rate

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing increased to a new high of 98.19 percent, compared to the April low of 95.04 percent. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at long-term risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

The S&P 500 is at a precarious 25.4 times projected earnings, a level only exceeded during the Dotcom bubble in 2000.

S&P 500 Forward Price-Earnings Ratio

Conclusion

The bull-bear indicator at 40% warns of a bear market ahead, while extreme pricing increases the long-term risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

Weak jobs and falling crude = September rate cut

Key Points

  • The Fed will likely cut interest rates in September after a weak jobs report.
  • Falling crude oil prices also ease inflationary pressure.
  • Long-term Treasury yields fall, anticipating a rate cut.
  • The dollar weakened as yields softened, while gold soared to a new high of $3,600 per ounce.

The August labor report disappointed with a low 22,000 job growth compared to an expected 75,000. Another June data revision saw jobs contract by 13,000, after initial reported gains of 147,000 were revised down to 14,000 last month.

Employment Growth

Growth in total weekly hours worked came to a complete halt in August, with annual growth falling to 0.7%. Real GDP growth will likely follow.

Total Hours Worked

The uptrend in continued claims confirms the August rise in the unemployment rate to 4.3%.

Unemployment

The unemployment level ( 7.4m ) now exceeds job openings ( 7.2m ), but only by 200K.

Job Openings

Temporary jobs fell to 2.5 million, a level typically seen during recessions.

Temporary Employment

Layoffs and discharges are in an uptrend.

Layoffs & Discharges Rate

The 2.0% quit rate indicates that employees are no longer confident in finding new jobs.

Quit Rate

Average hourly earnings growth slowed to an annualized rate of 3.3% in August, but year/year growth was steady at 3.9%, still indicating a balanced labor market.

Average Hourly Earnings

Crude Oil

OPEC+ has injected a lot of downside pricing risk into the oil markets this week, fueling speculation that the second wave of voluntary cuts totaling 1.65 million b/d could be unwound much quicker than previously expected. According to news reports, Saudi Arabia is interested in pushing ahead with the unwinding during the September 7 meeting, citing the need to regain market share. (OilPrice.com)

The move has the potential to create a massive oversupply. Brent crude fell to $65.50 per barrel on Friday, but if the Saudis succeed, expect a test of support at $60. Falling crude prices would squeeze shale producer margins, causing a drop in US production.

Brent Crude

Lower energy prices would ease inflationary pressures in the US, allowing more room for Fed rate cuts.

ISM Services

The ISM services PMI improved to 52% in August, indicating expansion.

ISM Services PMI

New orders jumped to 56%, signaling an improving outlook.

ISM Services New Orders

However, services employment signals contraction, confirming the weak labor report.

ISM Services Employment

A steep 69.2% for the prices sub-index also warns of strong inflationary pressures.

ISM Services Prices

Contracting employment and rising prices in the large services sector warn of stagflation. We expect the Fed to cut in September, but then pause to see how this affects prices.

Stocks

A weak labor report is a bearish sign for stocks despite the prospect of a Fed rate cut. A reversal of the S&P 500 below support at 6400 would warn of a correction.

S&P 500

We expect the Dow Jones Industrial Average to test support at 45,000. Respect of support would confirm another advance. A breach is less likely, but would signal a test of 44,000.

Dow Jones Industrial Average

Financial Markets

The Chicago Fed Index retreated to -0.526, warning that financial conditions are tightening.

Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index

Tighter financial conditions are also highlighted by a decline in bank reserves to below $3.2 trillion.

Commercial Bank Reserves at the Fed

Bitcoin is testing support at 110K. A breach would warn of a swing to risk-off in financial markets, which would be bearish for stocks.

Bitcoin (BTC)

Treasury Markets

10-year Treasury yields plunged to 4.09%, heading for a test of long-term support at 4.0% as speculators pile into bonds ahead of the expected September rate cut. However, we have warned of the risk that long-term yields rise in response to a Fed cut — as in September last year.

10-Year Treasury Yield

Dollar & Gold

The dollar weakened in response to the poor jobs report, anticipating falling interest rates.

Dollar Index

Gold surged to a new high at $3,600 per ounce before closing at $3,587. Expect another test of support at $3,500, but respect will likely confirm another advance — and our year-end target of $4,000.

Spot Gold

Silver is retracing to test support at $40, but respect will likely confirm another advance and a target of $44.

Spot Silver

Conclusion

Weak jobs growth in August warns that economic growth is slowing, but the ISM services report warns of strong price pressures in the services sector. We expect a Fed rate cut in September but then a pause as the Fed remains wary of stagflation, with low growth and rising prices.

We expect the dollar to weaken in response to rate cuts, with gold and silver soaring to new highs.

The Fed should take care to avoid a repeat of last September, when Fed rate cuts sparked a sell-off in long-term Treasuries, signaling the bond market’s displeasure with monetary and fiscal policy. We believe they will aim for a gradual decline, with a pause after the September cut to assess the impact of tariffs and a slowing economy on prices.

A Saudi move to increase crude oil production would likely drive Brent crude to $60 per barrel or below, giving the Fed more room to cut rates.

Acknowledgments

US Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, and the one on the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

The Bull/Bear indicator remains at 40%, warning of a bear market ahead.

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index declined to -0.555, indicating easy monetary conditions are supporting stocks and bonds.

Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index

Continued unemployment claims increased to 1.972 million on August 9, but the unemployment rate held steady at 4.2% in July. Fed Chair Powell highlighted the changing labor market dynamics in his Jackson Hole address on Friday. Job gains may decline due to falling immigration, but rising unemployment claims indicate a slowing economy. A rising unemployment rate for August would confirm a weakening labor market and open the door to a Fed rate cut in September.

Continued Unemployment Claims & Unemployment Rate

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing increased to a new high of 97.98 percent, compared to a low of 95.04 percent in April. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

Robert Shiller’s CAPE edged higher to 38.7, the highest ever recorded outside of the Dotcom bubble. CAPE compares the current S&P 500 index to a ten-year average of inflation-adjusted earnings.

Robert Shiller's CAPE

The S&P 500 price-to-sales ratio of 3.08 is the highest since our data began in 2000, and more than 70% above our long-term average of 1.78.

S&P 500 Price-to-Sales

Conclusion

The bull-bear indicator at 40% warns of a bear market ahead, while extreme pricing increases the risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

US Market Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, and the one on the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

The Bull/Bear indicator remains at 60%, with two of five leading indicators signaling risk-off:

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index declined to -0.51, reflecting strong liquidity in financial markets. Values above zero indicate restrictive financial conditions.

Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index

Weekly continued claims are climbing, warning of a deteriorating labor market despite the low 4.1% unemployment rate.

Continued Claims & Unemployment Rate

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing eased slightly to 97.34 percent, compared to a low of 95.04 percent in April and a high of 97.79 percent in February. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

Robert Shiller’s CAPE compares the current value of the S&P 500 index to inflation-adjusted earnings for the preceding 10 years. The multiple of 37.69 is similar to the last leg of the Dotcom bull market in 1999, warning that stocks are dangerously overpriced.

Robert Shiller's CAPE 10 Ratio

Conclusion

We are bordering on a bear market, with the bull-bear indicator at 60%. However, extreme stock pricing increases the risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

US Market Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, and the one on the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

The Bull/Bear indicator remains at 60%, with two of five leading indicators signaling risk-off:

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The declining Fed Funds target rate indicates monetary easing, a bearish sign for the economy, while the University of Michigan survey of current economic conditions also warns of recession. However, the other two composite indicators are bullish: the Chicago Fed index of national financial conditions signals strong liquidity, and S&P 500 smoothed momentum remains positive.

In June, employment in cyclical industries—manufacturing, construction, transportation, and warehousing—grew by 10K.

Cyclical Employment Growth

Unemployment declined to 4.1%, but weekly continued claims are trending upward, warning that the labor market is deteriorating.

Continued Claims & Unemployment Rate

Also, aggregate hours worked declined in June, with year-on-year growth slowing to 0.8%. GDP growth is likely to follow.

Aggregate Hours Worked

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing increased to 97.44, compared to a low of 95.04 eleven weeks ago and a high of 97.79 percent in February. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

The S&P 500 PE ratio is based on highest trailing earnings to eliminate distortions caused by sharp earnings falls during recessions. The current value of 28.5 is close to the 97th percentile of readings over the past fifty years.

S&P 500 PE of Highest Trailing Earnings

Conclusion

We are in the early stages of a bear market, with the bull-bear indicator at 60%. However, extreme stock pricing increases the risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

US Market Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, while the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

The Bull/Bear indicator remains at 60%, with two of five leading indicators signaling risk-off:

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

Weekly continued claims increased to 1.974 million on June 14, warning that the labor market is deteriorating. Unemployment was at 4.2% in May, but will likely rise in the next few months.

Continued Claims & Unemployment Rate

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing increased to 96.96, compared to a low of 95.04 ten weeks ago and a high of 97.79 percent in February. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

Robert Shiller’s CAPE compares the S&P 500 index against a ten-year average of inflation-adjusted earnings. CAPE increased to 37.29, approaching its December 2021 high of 38.31, which was only previously surpassed during the Dotcom bubble of 1999-2000.

Robert Shiller's CAPE

The previous high was 32.56, before the stock market crash of October 1929, shown on Shiller’s long-term chart below.

Robert Shiller's CAPE

Conclusion

We are in the early stages of a bear market, with the bull-bear indicator at 60%. Extreme stock pricing increases the risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

US Market Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, while the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

Our Bull/Bear Market indicator remains at 60%, with two of five leading indicators signaling risk-off:

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The unemployment rate remains at a low 4.2% in May, but weekly continued claims climbed to 1.945 million on June 7, warning that the labor market is deteriorating.

Continued Claims & Unemployment Rate

However, monetary conditions are easing. The Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index declined to -0.52 on June 13, signaling improved financial conditions.

Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing eased slightly to 96.30, compared to a low of 95.04 nine weeks ago and a high of 97.79 percent in February. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

Conclusion

We are in the early stages of a bear market, with the bull-bear indicator at 60%. Stock pricing is extreme, indicating risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

US Market Leading Indicators

Bull/Bear Market Indicator
Stock Market Pricing Indicator

The gauge on the left indicates bull or bear market status, while the right reflects stock market drawdown risk.

Bull/Bear Market

Our Bull/Bear Market indicator remains at 60%, with two of five leading indicators signaling risk-off:

Bull-Bear Market Indicator

The National Financial Conditions Index from the Chicago Fed dipped to -0.606, signaling monetary easing.

Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index

However, outside of the 2022 COVID pandemic, the University of Michigan index of current economic conditions is at the lowest recorded level since its inception in 1960.

University of Michigan: Current Economic Conditions

Also, continued unemployment claims rose to 1.92 million on May 17, a 39% increase in the four-week moving average from its low in June 2022. However, the unemployment rate remains at 4.2% and does not warrant serious concern until it reaches 5.0%.

Continued Claims & Unemployment Rate

Stock Pricing

Stock pricing increased to 96.51, compared to 95.04 six weeks ago and a high of 97.79 percent in February. The extreme reading warns that stocks are at risk of a significant drawdown.

Stock Market Value Indicator

We use z-scores to measure each indicator’s current position relative to its history, with the result expressed in standard deviations from the mean. We then calculate an average for the five readings and convert that to a percentile. The higher that stock market pricing is relative to its historical mean, the greater the risk of a sharp drawdown.

Conclusion

We remain in the early stages of a bear market, with the bull-bear indicator at 60%. Stock pricing is extreme, with elevated risk of a significant drawdown.

Acknowledgments

Notes

Inflation spooks Treasuries and stocks

Rising inflation expectations and robust economic data mean the Fed will likely pause rate cuts for several months. Stocks reacted negatively, but gold seemed unfazed.

The US economy shows slow but steady growth, with total weekly hours worked growing at an annual rate of 1.0% compared to real GDP at 2.5% in 2024.

Real GDP & Total Hours Worked

Heavy truck sales, a reliable leading indicator, fell sharply in December but rebounded to a robust 44.5K in January.

Heavy Truck Sales

Another reliable leading indicator is employment in cyclical sectors, which also shows robust growth. In a recession, manufacturing, construction, and transportation & warehousing typically shed far more jobs than the rest of the economy.Employment in Cyclical Sectors: Manufacturing, Construction, and Transport & Warehousing

ISM Survey

ISM business surveys show continued expansion in the services sector in January.

ISM Services PMI

It was joined by a manufacturing recovery above 50% after 26 months of contraction.

ISM Manufacturing PMI

Labor Market

The labor market added a modest 143K jobs in January.

Employment Growth

However, the unemployment rate fell to 4.0% from 4.2% in November, possibly aided by a surge in deportations.

Unemployment

Average weekly hours worked fell to 34.1 for the first time since the 2020 pandemic. This typically serves as an early warning of increased layoffs. Employers first cut back hours before shedding staff.

Average Weekly Hours

Lower weekly hours is contradicted by the JOLTS report, which showed job openings exceeding unemployment in December.

Job Openings

Average Hourly Earnings

A sharp increase in average hourly earnings, showing 4.1% growth for the 12 months to January, will likely cause concern at the Fed.

Average Hourly Earnings

December earnings growth surprised, at close to 0.5% for the month or 5.7% annualized.

Average Hourly Earnings - Monthly

University of Michigan Survey

Consumer sentiment dipped slightly in February, with the 3-month moving average declining to 71. Sentiment remains below levels during the 2020 pandemic.

University of Michigan: Consumer Sentiment

The current economic conditions index declined to 68.7 in February, but the 3-month MA is still rising.

University of Michigan: Current Economic Conditions

Expectations are also falling, with the 3-month MA declining to 70.

University of Michigan: Consumer Expectations

Financial markets were spooked by the sharp jump in expected price increases in the next 12 months, which reached 4.3% in February, with the 3-month MA at 3.5%.

University of Michigan: 1-Year Inflation Expectations

Five-year inflation expectations are also rising, with the 3-month MA climbing to 3.2% in February.

University of Michigan: 5-Year Inflation Expectations

Treasury Market

Ten-year Treasury yields rallied in response to the stronger inflation outlook, testing resistance at 4.5%. Recovery above the descending trendline would warn of another advance.

10-Year Treasury Yield

Stocks

The S&P 500 fell sharply in response to the prospect of higher interest rates. Breach of 5850 would signal a test of primary support at 5800.

S&P 500

Dollar & Gold

The Dollar rallied, testing resistance at 108 in response to higher interest rates. Breakout would offer a short-term target of 110.

Dollar Index

Gold is retracing to test support at $2,850 per ounce. Respect would signal a test of $3,000.

Spot Gold

Silver broke its new support level at $32 per ounce, warning of retracement to test $30.

Spot Silver

Conclusion

Strong growth in average hourly earnings and rising consumer inflation expectations will likely cause the Fed to pause rate cuts until the current uptrend reverses. That could take more than six months.

10-year Treasury yields are expected to resume their uptrend. Recovery above 4.5% would confirm.

Rising long-term yields are bearish for stocks, with the S&P 500 likely to test primary support at 5800.

The Dollar Index is also expected to resume its uptrend. Breakout above 108 would signal another test of resistance at 110.

Gold is expected to continue its uptrend, with a breakout above $2,900 per ounce signaling a test of $3,000 for the first time. Rising inflation expectations and increased bullion holdings by foreign central banks will likely maintain a shortage of physical gold.

Acknowledgments

ASX 200 jumps to new high

A strong September jobs report boosted the ASX 200 to a new high of 8355, confirming our target of 8500 for this year.

Labor Market

The Australian economy added a seasonally adjusted 64,100 jobs in September, according to the latest Labour Report, well above expectations of 25,000.

Australia: Employment

The unemployment rate remained steady at 4.1%.

Australia: Unemployment

The surge in jobs was absorbed by an increase in the participation rate to a robust 67.2%.

Australia: Participation Rate

Aggregate hours worked also improved to 1,968 million in September, a 0.3% increase compared to the 0.2% average over the past 12 months.

Australia: Aggregate Hours Worked

Business

Strong labor conditions failed to inspire business confidence, with NAB business confidence (black below) declining to -6 pts in the third quarter.

NAB Business Confidence

Wage costs were the number#1 issue affecting business confidence:

Issues Affecting Business Confidence

The Mining industry (red below) recorded a sharp drop in confidence.

NAB Business Confidence by Industry

Stocks

The ASX 200 rallied through resistance at 8300, confirming our year-end target of 8500.

ASX 200 Index

The ASX 200 rally was led by a strong surge in Financials, which is headed for a test of resistance at 8600.

ASX 200 Financials Index

The ASX 300 Metals & Mining Index remains tentative, weighed down by falling demand from China. Breach of support at 5600 would warn of another test of long-term support at 5000.

ASX 300 Metals & Mining Index

On the other hand, the All Ordinaries Gold Index is testing its July 2020 high at 9500. Breakout would offer a long-term target of 14500. The soaring gold price and falling energy costs have boosted margins, with diesel a substantial cost in extraction and transportation.

All Ordinaries Gold Index

Conclusion

A strong jobs report boosted the ASX 200, which recorded a new high of 8355, confirming our target of 8500 for the year.

Strong employment growth suggests that the RBA is unlikely to cut interest rates before next year. Instead, the hawks will be keeping a beady eye on inflation.

Business confidence remains low, with Mining especially hard hit by sluggish demand from China.

The Financials sub-index is headed for a test of resistance at 8600. Breakout would offer a medium-term target of 9200. The All Ords Gold Index is also bullish, testing its 2020 high of 9500. Breakout would offer a long-term target of 14500. Metals & Mining, however, remain bearish.

Acknowledgments