Rising long-term rates could spoil the party

Real GDP for the September quarter reflects an annual growth rate of 2.9% for the US, well below the Atlanta Fed GDPNow estimate of 5.4%. Growth in weekly hours worked declined to 1.5% for the 12 months ended September, indicating that GDP is likely to slow further in the fourth quarter.

Real GDP & Estimated Total Weekly Hours

New Orders

Manufacturers’ new orders for durable goods, adjusted for inflation, shows signs of strengthening.

Manufacturers' New Orders: Durable Goods

Transport

Transport indicators show a long-term down-trend but truck tonnage has grown since May 2023.

Truck Tonnage

Container (intermodal) rail freight likewise grew for several months but then turned down in August..

Rail Freight

Growth in weekly payrolls of transport and warehousing employees slowed to an annual rate of 3.6% in September but remains positive.

Transport & Warehousing Weekly Payrolls

Consumer Cyclical

Light vehicle sales continue to trend higher, suggesting consumer confidence.

Light Vehicle Sales

Housing

New housing starts (purple) have been trending lower since their peak in 2022 but new permits (green) are now strengthening.

Housing Starts & Permits

New single family houses sold are trending higher.

New Home Sales

Despite a steep rise in mortgage rates. In a strange twist, higher rates have reduced the turnover of existing homes on the market, with owners reluctant to give up their low fixed rate mortgages. Low supply of existing homes has boosted sales of new homes, lifting employment in residential construction.

30-Year Mortgage Rate

The National Association of Home Builders Housing Market Index (HMI), however, reflects falling sentiment — likely to be followed by declining new home sales and housing starts.

NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index

HMI is a weighted average of three separate component indices. A monthly survey of NAHB members asks respondents to rate market conditions for the sale of new homes at the present time; sales in the next six months; and the traffic of prospective buyers. (NAHB)

Financial Markets

The ratio of bank loans and leases to GDP declined to 0.44 in the third quarter but remains elevated compared to levels prior to 2000.

Bank Loans & Leases

The cause of ballooning debt is not hard to find, with negative real interest rates for large parts of the past two decades.

Real Fed Funds Rate

Now real rates are again positive and money supply is contracting relative to GDP, the days of easy credit are at an end. A significant contraction of credit is likely unless the Fed intervenes, either by cutting rates or expanding its balance sheet to inject more liquidity into the system.

M2 Money Supply/GDP

Commercial banks continued to raise lending standards in Q3, making credit less accessible.

Bank Lending Standards

Conclusion

This is not a normal market cycle and investors need to be prepared for sudden shifts in financial markets.

The US economy is slowing but cyclical elements like light vehicle sales and new home sales are holding up well.

The rise in long-term Treasury yields, however, is likely to cause a sharp credit contraction if the Fed does not intervene by cutting rates or expanding its balance sheet (QE).

10-Year Treasury Yields

The Fed is reluctant to intervene because this would undermine their efforts to curb inflation. But they may be forced to if there is a credit event that unsettles financial markets.

Moody's Baa Corporate Bond Yield minus 10-Year Treasury Yield

Fed intervention is unlikely without a steep rise in credit spreads. But would be especially bullish for Gold.

CPI dips but rate hikes likely to continue

CPI dipped to 8.5% for the 12 months to July. But this still leaves the Fed way behind the curve, with a real Fed funds rate of -6.0% (8.5%-2.5%).

CPI

Monthly CPI figures, however, show a sharp slowdown, with CPI falling 0.01% in July (-0.14% annualized rate).

CPI Monthly

The primary cause is energy prices, which fell 4.53% in July (-54.7% annualized rate).

CPI Energy (Monthly Annualized)

Food CPI continues to climb, up 1.06%for July (12.75% annualized rate).

CPI: Food

CPI Shelter, heavily weighted at 32.1% of the total CPI basket, remains a major source of upward pressure on CPI. The Shelter index tends to lag home prices by up to 12 months and the Case-Shiller 20-City Composite Home Price Index grew at 20.8% for the 12 months to May.

CPI: Shelter

The Rents component of CPI shelter shows a similar lag, a long way behind the Zillow rent index which is up 14.8% over the 12 months to June.

CPI: Rent

Wages & consumer expectations

Consumer expectations for inflation were unchanged, at 5.3% in June.

University of Michigan: Inflation Expectations

While average hourly wage rates moderated slightly, growing 6.2% in the 12 months to July.

Average Hourly Earnings

Upward pressure on wages is likely to continue for as long as job openings exceed unemployment, with a current shortfall of 5 million workers.

Job Openings & Unemployment (U3)

The Fed

The real Fed funds rate (FFR adjusted for CPI) rose to a weak -6.0% after the latest rate hike, still lower than any previous trough in the past sixty years. Real FFR (red below) should be positive when unemployment (blue) is below 5%. Past lows, circled on the chart below, were in response to high unemployment — when the economy had spare capacity. We now have the opposite, with a tight labor market, and negative real rates are likely to give rise to high inflation.

Unemployment (U3) & Fed Funds Rate - CPI

Conclusion

Some are calling this “peak inflation” but the decline in CPI growth is due to a large monthly drop in energy prices. Food and shelter costs are still rising.

The energy crisis is not over, with Winter approaching in Europe while gas storage levels are at record lows and Russia is restricting pipeline flows in an attempt to create division within the European Union. Energy prices are likely to remain volatile.

The Fed is way behind the curve, with a real Fed funds rate of -6.0%. We expect them to continue hiking interest rates despite the recent fall in energy prices.

According to Larry Summers and Olivier Blanchard, the Fed will only be able to bring inflation down when unemployment is well above 5%. The danger is if the Fed is forced to halt rate hikes before it has tamed underlying inflation. We are then likely to end up with both low growth and high inflation.

Our strategy remains defensive: overweight Gold, critical materials, defensive stocks which enjoy strong pricing power, and cash.

Acknowledgements