Great stock market analogy from Eric Cinnamond at Palm Valley Capital:
As a kid I always looked forward to Halloween. Growing up in a health-conscious “no sweets” household, Halloween was an opportunistic time to load up on my favorite chocolate bars and candy. If I played my bag of treats right, my sweet tooth could be satisfied until Christmas!
Another thing I enjoyed about Halloween was the television special, It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown. It was and remains a classic. Released in 1966, the Peanuts special follows its cast members as they celebrate Halloween. Some of the Peanuts crew go trick-or-treating, while others attend a party. But not Linus—he does his own thing.
Instead of celebrating with his friends, Linus spends his Halloween waiting in a pumpkin patch for the Great Pumpkin. According to Linus, “On Halloween night, the Great Pumpkin rises from his pumpkin patch and flies through the air with his bag of toys to all the children.” Unfortunately, the Great Pumpkin never arrives, and Linus is ridiculed by his friends. He’s even called a blockhead!
Our belief in full market cycles, including a bull and bear market, is beginning to feel more and more like Linus’s belief in the Great Pumpkin. However, instead of pumpkins, we sit in a patch of T-bills waiting for the return of sensible equity valuations. And rather than bringing a bag of toys, we expect this cycle’s Great Pumpkin (bear market) will bring patient investors the gift of lower prices and opportunity.
From the outside looking in, believing in full market cycles, bear markets, and even recessions, probably looks foolish. To some, we might even look like blockheads! Nevertheless, we continue to believe equity valuations are very expensive, exposing investors to considerable risk. In fact, we consider this stage of the market cycle to be an asset bubble—the third stock market bubble of our careers. The first two bubbles were verified by significant losses, with the S&P 500 losing half of its value during both bear markets (2000-2002 -49% and 2007-2009 -56%).
Our latest page on stock market valuation supports his view:
