Japan’s Debt Trap

Key Points

  • Japanese PM Sanae Takaichi led her Liberal Democratic Party to a resounding 316 out of 465 seats win in Sunday’s snap election for Japan’s lower house.
  • The Yen strengthened, and long-term bond yields declined on the result.
  • The Japanese government is in a debt trap caused by precarious debt levels, negative real interest rates, a weakening Yen, and rising inflation.

Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi delivered the country’s first post-war supermajority in Sunday’s snap election. Her Liberal Democratic Party won 316 out of 465 seats in Japan’s powerful lower house.

The arch-conservative leader has pledged to suspend the 8% sales tax on food, called for a return to the large-scale fiscal stimulus deployed by former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (2006-2007 and 2012-2020), and wants to revise Japan’s pacifist constitution. (Reuters)

The Japanese Yen strengthened against the Dollar, but remains in a long-term downtrend. The Yen has weakened considerably since Takaichi’s appointment in October 2025. However, currency markets hope that Takaichi’s resounding victory will ease pressure to adopt populist policies.

Japanese Yen

Japan has struggled to recover since industrial production plateaued in the 1990s.

Japanese Industrial Production

Japanese fiscal debt ballooned as the government ran large deficits to stimulate the economy. Now, fears of rising inflation have driven up long-term interest rates, threatening a fiscal crisis as debt-servicing costs rise.

Japanese Fiscal Debt to GDP

Takaichi seeks to follow a fiscal path similar to that of Japan’s longest-serving prime minister, Shinzo Abe, with large-scale fiscal stimulus now known as “Abenomics.” However, inflation is much higher than during Abe’s tenure, which ended in 2020. Japanese core CPI excluding food and energy (termed “core core” in Japan), remains stubbornly high at 2.9%.

Japanese CPI Inflation Excluding Food & Energy

The Bank of Japan has slow-walked the pace of increases in its policy rate, which remains deeply negative at -2.15% (0.75% minus 2.9%), heightening fears of high inflation.

Bank of Japan Policy Rate

Rising Japanese interest rates, accompanied by a weakening Yen, have alerted bond markets to a potential fiscal crisis. Rising rates typically strengthen the domestic currency by attracting inflows of foreign capital. The weakening Yen warns of the opposite: capital outflows despite higher interest rates, as bond markets are wary of inflation risk.

Bond markets are demanding increased compensation for inflation risk, with the 30-year Japanese bond yield climbing above 3.75% before retracing to test support at 3.5% after the snap election result.

30-Year JGB Yield

Japanese stocks have also soared on expectations of higher inflation, with the Nikkei 225 index in a strong uptrend.

Nikkei 225 Index

Conclusion

Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaich’s resounding victory in Sunday’s snap election provides her with the political cover needed to make the tough decisions necessary to avoid a fiscal crisis. Whether she is sufficiently pragmatic to seize this opportunity will become evident in the months ahead.

Japan is in a debt trap.

The pursuit of large fiscal stimulus risks a budgetary crisis as higher inflation drives up bond yields, threatening a budget blowout. Intervention by the Bank of Japan to suppress long-term interest rates through large bond purchases would risk a currency crisis, with a collapse of the Yen.

Japan’s long-term bond yields are artificially low, supported by the Bank of Japan’s large-scale bond purchases. The chart below from Robin Brooks compares JGB 30-year yields (JP) with the yield on Germany’s 30-year Bund (DE). Both bonds offer similar yields despite substantial differences in the two countries’ debt-to-GDP ratios.

30-Year JGB Yield vs. German 30-Year Yield

We expect that the Yen will continue to weaken until the above disparity is rectified, with capital flowing out of Japan into more secure markets.

A weak Yen, or higher Japanese interest rates, has far-reaching implications beyond Japan’s domestic bond market. Japanese investors hold $11 trillion of international investments. Rising domestic interest rates, a falling Yen, or attempts to support the Yen by selling reserve assets — can destabilize international capital markets, driving up long-term bond yields.

Acknowledgments

Bernard Connolly: Why the Euro Crisis Isn't Over | WSJ.com

From Brian Carney’s weekend interview with Bernard Connolly:

…But even if the Greeks were undisciplined, he says, “both the sovereign-debt crisis and the banking crisis are symptoms, not causes. And the underlying problem has been that there was a massive bubble generated in the world as a whole by monetary policy—but particularly in the euro zone” by European Central Bank policy.

The bubble formed like this: When countries such as Ireland, Greece and Spain joined the euro, their interest rates immediately dropped to near-German levels, in some cases from double-digit territory. “The optimism created by these countries’ suddenly finding that they could have low interest rates without their currencies collapsing, which had been their previous experience, led people to think that there was a genuine rate-of-return revolution going on,” he says.

There had been an increase in the rates of return in Ireland “and to some extent in Spain” in the run-up to euro membership, thanks to structural reforms in those countries in the pre-euro period. But by the time the euro rolled around, money was flowing into these countries out of all proportion to the opportunities available…..

Read more at The Weekend Interview with Bernard Connolly: Why the Euro Crisis Isn't Over – WSJ.com.

The eurozone’s double-dip recession is entirely self-made. | EUROPP

Good comparison of relative unit labor costs for EZ countries in this article by Paul De Grauwe. Germany is lowest at 85-90. Greece and Portugal highest at 110-115, with Italy, Spain and Belgium next at 105-110. Ireland has made the most spectacular recovery, falling to 95 from a high 115-120 in 2007.

The position of Germany stands out. During 1999-2007, Germany engineered a significant internal devaluation that contributed to its economic recovery and the build-up of external surpluses.

via The eurozone’s double-dip recession is entirely self-made. | EUROPP.

IMF: Coping with high debt and sluggish growth [video]

The World Economic Outlook (WEO) presents the IMF staff’s analysis and projections of economic developments at the global level, in major country groups (classified by region, stage of development, etc.), and in many individual countries.

[gigya src=”http://c.brightcove.com/services/viewer/federated_f9?isVid=1″ bgcolor=”#FFFFFF” flashVars=”videoId=1864410651001&playerID=45533486001&playerKey=AQ~~,AAAACofWkTk~,d-cWVfCeeBH2u4-MzWQrjKX5_f_MoDWg&domain=embed&dynamicStreaming=true” base=”http://admin.brightcove.com” name=”flashObj” width=”486″ height=”412″ seamlesstabbing=”false” type=”application/x-shockwave-flash” allowFullScreen=”true” swLiveConnect=”true” allowScriptAccess=”always” pluginspage=”http://www.macromedia.com/shockwave/download/index.cgi?P1_Prod_Version=ShockwaveFlash”]

[time: 38 minutes]

There's No Solving Europe's Debt Crisis Without Solving the Jobs Crisis – Bloomberg

From the outside it looks like these [Eurozone] countries are faced with a debt crisis. From the inside it looks a lot more like a jobs crisis. Check out the chart below…….

via There’s No Solving Europe’s Debt Crisis Without Solving the Jobs Crisis – Bloomberg.

Hat tip to @10yearBonds

ECB Unveils Bond-Buying Program – WSJ.com

By GEOFFREY T. SMITH

The ECB will buy in the secondary market only government bonds with remaining maturities between one and three years without announcing any limits in advance, and as long as the government in question is under a program approved by the euro zone.

The measures will primarily benefit fiscally troubled countries like Spain and Italy, which are facing difficulties financing their budget deficits…

via ECB Unveils Bond-Buying Program – WSJ.com.

The work of John Maynard Keynes shows us that counter-cyclical fiscal policy and an easing of austerity may offer a way out of the Eurozone crisis. | EUROPP

Simon Wren-Lewis, professor at Oxford University and a Fellow of Merton College, says the ECB failed to undertake quantitative easing at the appropriate time because of mis-diagnosis of the problem:

The story told by many is that the Eurozone crisis is a result of fiscal profligacy in some countries, and the need to put that right quickly because of market pressure. This account misses two essential underlying causes of the crisis, which have to be recognised if a solution is to be found. The first missing element ….. private sector demand was too strong, encouraged by large capital inflows from abroad and real estate bubbles…..The second key feature of the current crisis is also a result of excess private sector demand in periphery countries, and that is a banking crisis.

……There is an underlying pattern behind Eurozone policy errors. They reflect a view that macroeconomic difficulties are primary due to bad government decisions, while private sector decisions within a free market environment do not create problems. Whatever label we want to give this view (Ordoliberal or Anti-Keynesian), it is the fundamental cause of the current Eurozone crisis. Its persistence despite all the contrary evidence allows the crisis to continue and threatens the integrity of the Eurozone itself.

via The work of John Maynard Keynes shows us that counter-cyclical fiscal policy and an easing of austerity may offer a way out of the Eurozone crisis. | EUROPP.

Germany backs Draghi bond plan against Bundesbank – Telegraph

By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard,
9:39PM BST 20 Aug 2012

“A currency can only be stable if its future existence is not in doubt,” said Jörg Asmussen, the powerful German member of the ECB’s executive board. He signalled full backing for the bond rescue plan of ECB chief Mario Draghi, brushing aside warnings from the German Bundesbank that large-scale purchases would amount to debt monetisation and a back-door fiscal rescue of insolvent states in breach of EU treaty law.

via Germany backs Draghi bond plan against Bundesbank – Telegraph.

Italian's Job: Premier Talks Tough in Bid to Save Euro – WSJ.com

Only the ECB has the necessary firepower to move the market. Senior German officials say the ECB’s help is what [Italian premier Mario] Monti has really been after all along. The Italian leader is convinced that the June 28 summit provided political cover for the ECB to take bold action, in the knowledge that euro-zone governments—including Germany—won’t oppose it.

“I have no doubt that the night before the disintegration of the euro, the ECB will do whatever is necessary to save it,” Mr. Monti says. “The question is: Do we need to get to the night before?”

via Italian’s Job: Premier Talks Tough in Bid to Save Euro – WSJ.com.

Roubini Says 2013 `Storm' May Surpass 2008 Crisis

Nouriel Robini on Bloomberg TV: The Euro summit was a failure… markets were expecting much more. Either you have debt neutralization [EFSF purchases of government bonds] or debt monetization by the ECB or EFSF/ESM be doubled or tripled using leverage ….or you will have a worse crisis in the next few weeks.

The ability of politicians to kick the can down the road will run out of steam in 2013…..next year could be a global perfect storm

Bloomberg TV: Roubini Says 2013 `Storm’ May Surpass 2008 Crisis